|
Size: 3826
Comment:
|
Size: 6007
Comment:
|
| Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
| Line 7: | Line 7: |
| '''Additional Objectives''' To obtain user-in-the-loop and server-in-the-loop RMS variations. | '''Additional Objectives''' * To obtain user-in-the-loop and server-in-the-loop RMS error variations. * To obtain user-in-the-loop procedural variation. * To obtain beginner/expert user variation. |
| Line 15: | Line 18: |
| * emission * Every 20 degrees azimuth, 45 degree zenith angle * incidence * 0, 90, 180, 270, 45 zenith angle * 135 azimuth, 30 zenith angle |
* S/C: * Every 20° azimuth angle, 45° zenith angle * Sun: * 0, 90°, 180°, 270° azimuth angle, 45 zenith angle * 135° azimuth angle, 30° zenith angle Spacecraft: {{attachment:SC_perfectF2_POLARS.jpg||width=300}} Sun: {{attachment:SUN_perfectF2_POLARS.jpg||width=300}} |
| Line 23: | Line 34: |
| ||'''User'''||'''Server'''||'''Number of Core Processors'''|| ||TCampbell||?Ormacsrv2||?8|| ||KDrozd||Ormacsrv1||8|| ||Dlambert||Ormacsrv3||6|| ||EPalmer||?||?|| ||JWeirich||DD||12|| |
||'''User'''||'''Experience'''||'''Server'''||'''Number of Core Processors'''|| ||TCampbell||Intermediate||?Ormacsrv2||?8|| ||KDrozd||Intermediate||Ormacsrv1||8|| ||DLambert||Beginner||Ormacsrv3||6|| ||EPalmer||Experienced||?||?|| ||JWeirich||Intermediate||DD||12|| |
| Line 34: | Line 45: |
| Starting topography defined from: ? | Starting topography defined from: START1.MAP: * GSD = 25cm; * Q size = 150; * width = 75m; * center lat/wlong = -8.027, 262.768. |
| Line 36: | Line 51: |
| ||Step||GSD||Overlap Ratio||Q Size||Width|| | '''DTM Bigmap parameters:''' ||Step||GSD(cm)||Overlap Factor||Approx. Overlap Percentage||Q Size||Width|| ||35cm-Tiling||35||1.3||60%||112||60m|| ||18cm-Tiling||18||1.3||60%||217||61m|| ||9cm-Tiling||9||1.3||60%||434||61m|| ||5cm-Tiling||5||1.3||60%||780||62m|| '''Evaluation Bigmap parameters:''' * GSD = 5cm; * Q size = 500; * width = 50m; '''Tiling Parameters''' Tiling parameters may have varied between users: ||Parameter||TCampbell||KDrozd||DLambert||EPalmer||JWeirich|| ||Image elimination: INVLIM||0||0||0||?||0|| ||Image elimination: SLIM||60 (@35cm), 50 (o.w.)||50||60 (@35cm), 50 (o.w.)||?||50|| ||Image elimination: CLIM||.5||.5||.5||?||.5|| ||Image elimination: ILIM||.5||.5||.5||?||.5|| ||Image elimination: RSMIN||0 (@35cm), .25 (o.w.)||.25||0 (@35cm), .25 (o.w.)||?||.25|| ||Image elimination: RSMAX||3||3||3||?||3|| ||Calculate Central Vector (v, 1)||YES||YES||YES||?||YES|| ||Differential Stereo (2, 6)||YES||YES||YES||?||YES|| ||Shadows (2, 7)||NO||NO||NO||?||NO|| |
| Line 40: | Line 81: |
| Reset albedo/slopes: ?YES Calculate Central Vector: ?YES Differential Stereo: ?YES Shadows: ?NO |
Iteration parameters varied between users: ||Parameter||TCampbell||KDrozd||DLambert||EPalmer||JWeirich|| ||Reset albedo/slopes (a, y, y)||NO||YES||YES||?||YES|| ||Calculate Central Vector (v, 1)||YES||YES||YES||?||YES|| ||Differential Stereo (2, 6)||NO||NO||NO||?||NO|| ||Shadows (2, 7)||NO||YES||NO||?||YES|| |
| Line 47: | Line 91: |
| Please see Tables and Figures. |
|
| Line 48: | Line 94: |
=== User Differences in Tiling and Iteration Parameters === The only differences in tiling parameters pertain to the auto-elimination of images during the initial 35cm tiling. The maximum permissible emission angle varied between 50 and 60 degrees. The minimum allowable ration between image scale and misplace varied between 0 and 0.25. All other tiling step parameters were the same between users. === User Differences in Processing Steps === === User Differences in Evaluation Statistics === |
Test 05: OptimalF2
Aim and Objectives
Purpose of test: To obtain highest possible topographic accuracy and resolution for TAG site 1, given perfect camera position and pointing and optimal SPC image suite.
Additional Objectives
- To obtain user-in-the-loop and server-in-the-loop RMS error variations.
- To obtain user-in-the-loop procedural variation.
- To obtain beginner/expert user variation.
Methodology
Data
- Data was generated by Imager_mg using shape3.8 on ormacsrv1.
- PT10A - Centered at the middle of TAG site one.
- Image Suite: Optimal flight path, image resolutions: 50cm, 20cm, 10cm, 5cm.
- S/C:
- Every 20° azimuth angle, 45° zenith angle
- Sun:
- 0, 90°, 180°, 270° azimuth angle, 45 zenith angle
- 135° azimuth angle, 30° zenith angle
- S/C:
Spacecraft:
Sun:
User/Server-in-the-loop:
User |
Experience |
Server |
Number of Core Processors |
TCampbell |
Intermediate |
?Ormacsrv2 |
?8 |
KDrozd |
Intermediate |
Ormacsrv1 |
8 |
DLambert |
Beginner |
Ormacsrv3 |
6 |
EPalmer |
Experienced |
? |
? |
JWeirich |
Intermediate |
DD |
12 |
Bigmaps
The following TAG1 bigmaps were tiled/iterated and evaluated:
Starting topography defined from: START1.MAP:
- GSD = 25cm;
- Q size = 150;
- width = 75m;
- center lat/wlong = -8.027, 262.768.
DTM Bigmap parameters:
Step |
GSD(cm) |
Overlap Factor |
Approx. Overlap Percentage |
Q Size |
Width |
35cm-Tiling |
35 |
1.3 |
60% |
112 |
60m |
18cm-Tiling |
18 |
1.3 |
60% |
217 |
61m |
9cm-Tiling |
9 |
1.3 |
60% |
434 |
61m |
5cm-Tiling |
5 |
1.3 |
60% |
780 |
62m |
Evaluation Bigmap parameters:
- GSD = 5cm;
- Q size = 500;
- width = 50m;
Tiling Parameters
Tiling parameters may have varied between users:
Parameter |
TCampbell |
KDrozd |
DLambert |
EPalmer |
JWeirich |
Image elimination: INVLIM |
0 |
0 |
0 |
? |
0 |
Image elimination: SLIM |
60 (@35cm), 50 (o.w.) |
50 |
60 (@35cm), 50 (o.w.) |
? |
50 |
Image elimination: CLIM |
.5 |
.5 |
.5 |
? |
.5 |
Image elimination: ILIM |
.5 |
.5 |
.5 |
? |
.5 |
Image elimination: RSMIN |
0 (@35cm), .25 (o.w.) |
.25 |
0 (@35cm), .25 (o.w.) |
? |
.25 |
Image elimination: RSMAX |
3 |
3 |
3 |
? |
3 |
Calculate Central Vector (v, 1) |
YES |
YES |
YES |
? |
YES |
Differential Stereo (2, 6) |
YES |
YES |
YES |
? |
YES |
Shadows (2, 7) |
NO |
NO |
NO |
? |
NO |
Iteration Parameters
Iteration parameters varied between users:
Parameter |
TCampbell |
KDrozd |
DLambert |
EPalmer |
JWeirich |
Reset albedo/slopes (a, y, y) |
NO |
YES |
YES |
? |
YES |
Calculate Central Vector (v, 1) |
YES |
YES |
YES |
? |
YES |
Differential Stereo (2, 6) |
NO |
NO |
NO |
? |
NO |
Shadows (2, 7) |
NO |
YES |
NO |
? |
YES |
Results
Please see Tables and Figures.
Discussion
User Differences in Tiling and Iteration Parameters
The only differences in tiling parameters pertain to the auto-elimination of images during the initial 35cm tiling. The maximum permissible emission angle varied between 50 and 60 degrees. The minimum allowable ration between image scale and misplace varied between 0 and 0.25. All other tiling step parameters were the same between users.
User Differences in Processing Steps
User Differences in Evaluation Statistics
Conclusions and Recommendations
Tables and Figures
RMS Distance (cm) - Compare OBJ
Resolution (cm) |
Step |
Diane |
Eric |
John |
Kris |
Tanner |
35 |
35cm-Tiling |
|
7.06 |
|
7.06 |
8.35 |
35 |
35cm-Iteration 1 |
|
6.95 |
|
7.15 |
8.49 |
35 |
35cm-Iteration 2 |
11.51 |
7.15 |
7.13 |
7.44 |
8.58 |
35 |
35cm-Iteration 3 |
11.76 |
7.6 |
|
7.44 |
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 4 |
11.85 |
8.04 |
|
9.10 |
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 5 |
11.31 |
7.57 |
|
11.05 |
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 6 |
|
8.81 |
|
13.39 |
|
18 |
18cm-Tiling |
8.78 |
|
5.43 |
8.79 |
6.49 |
18 |
18cm-Iteration 1 |
8.62 |
8.12 |
6.29 |
9.37 |
6.50 |
18 |
18cm-Iteration 2 |
8.57 |
|
7.45 |
10.60 |
6.58 |
18 |
18cm-Iteration 3 |
8.57 |
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 4 |
8.56 |
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 5 |
8.55 |
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 6 |
8.54 |
|
|
|
|
9 |
9cm-Tiling |
5.47 |
|
6.00 |
8.49 |
4.98 |
9 |
9cm-Iteration 1 |
5.28 |
|
7.39 |
9.80 |
4.92 |
9 |
9cm-Iteration 2 |
5.27 |
|
9.15 |
|
4.92 |
5 |
5cm-Tiling |
|
|
7.68 |
|
4.47 |
5 |
5cm-Iteration 1 |
|
|
12.31 |
|
4.44 |
5 |
5cm-Iteration 2 |
|
|
|
|
4.45 |
Formal Uncertainty (cm) - RESIDUALS
Resolution (cm) |
Step |
Diane |
Eric |
John |
Kris |
Tanner |
|
35 |
35cm-Tiling |
|
5.48 |
|
5.49 |
|
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 1 |
|
6.32 |
|
6.91 |
|
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 2 |
29.78 |
4.76 |
|
5.36 |
5.72 |
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 3 |
39.12 |
4.71 |
|
5.45 |
|
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 4 |
14.74 |
4.87 |
|
5.98 |
|
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 5 |
12.69 |
5.04 |
|
6.72 |
|
|
35 |
35cm-Iteration 6 |
|
5.23 |
|
7.51 |
|
|
18 |
18cm-Tiling |
8.78 |
9.17 |
|
3.12 |
5.11 |
4.34 |
18 |
18cm-Iteration 1 |
7.90 |
|
2.97 |
3.98 |
4.45 |
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 2 |
7.23 |
|
3.33 |
3.98 |
4.22 |
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 3 |
6.84 |
|
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 4 |
6.61 |
|
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 5 |
6.47 |
|
|
|
|
|
18 |
18cm-Iteration 6 |
6.40 |
|
|
|
|
|
9 |
9cm-Tiling |
3.82 |
|
2.24 |
2.86 |
2.54 |
|
9 |
9cm-Iteration 1 |
3.53 |
|
2.57 |
2.99 |
2.46 |
|
9 |
9cm-Iteration 2 |
3.18 |
|
3.01 |
|
2.26 |
|
5 |
5cm-Tiling |
|
|
2.99 |
|
1.59 |
|
5 |
5cm-Iteration 1 |
|
|
3.97 |
|
1.43 |
|
5 |
5cm-Iteration 2 |
|
|
|
|
1.35 |
35cm GSD Maplets - 50cm Resolution Images 
18cm GSD Maplets - 20cm Resolution Images 
9cm GSD Maplets - 10cm Resolution Images 