Differences between revisions 11 and 19 (spanning 8 versions)

Test F3F3: Clark and Tikir Photometric Function - Analysis

Since the Clark and Tikir photometric function behaved so differently to the Lommel-Seeliger photometric function during testing, the sub-test results are analyzed here in detail. The F3F3 sub-test digital terrain model (Clark and Tikir photometric function) suffered from pervasive degradation with every processing step performed, eventually failing to build topography for a subset of landmarks at the 5cm tiling step. This failure is illustrated by the 5cm Landmark Test, reported below.

5cm Landmark Test

Background: A subset of new landmarks (28 of 225) created during the 5cm tile failed to achieve minimum image correlations across the images. At 5cm each landmarks contains approximately 12 Detailed Survey PolyCam images. At this scale elimination of low correlating images is not allowed, instead low-correlating images must be aligned by hand. On investigation it was found that the lithos template degraded rapidly with iteration leading to rapid loss of image correlation scores. This behavior was found to be pervasive across landmarks of all latitudes within the TAG site region, all available viewing conditions and all ground sample distances (GSDs) including the start model landmarks at 35cm, 75cm, and 150cm GSD.

Methodology:

LITHOS Image Correlation Score During Template Building:
F3F1 - Lommel-Seeliger Photometric Function:

Picture Name	Start (0 Iterations)	50 Iterations	100 Iterations	250 Iterations	500 Iterations	800 Iterations	1000 Iterations
P601293196H2	0.839	0.896	0.928	0.959	0.963	0.962	0.962
P601293751H3	0.871	0.916	0.940	0.962	0.966	0.966	0.965
P601293757H3	0.871	0.918	0.942	0.964	0.968	0.967	0.967
P601372298H3	0.903	0.943	0.956	0.963	0.963	0.962	0.962
P601372304H3	0.902	0.943	0.958	0.965	0.965	0.965	0.964
P601372310H3	0.901	0.942	0.956	0.965	0.965	0.964	0.964
P601372316H3	0.902	0.943	0.957	0.965	0.965	0.965	0.964
P601372856H2	0.875	0.932	0.954	0.967	0.966	0.964	0.964
P601372862H2	0.874	0.931	0.954	0.967	0.966	0.965	0.964
P601372868H2	0.874	0.931	0.953	0.967	0.966	0.965	0.964
P601372874H2	0.874	0.931	0.953	0.967	0.966	0.964	0.964

F3F3 - Clark and Tikir Photometric Function:

Picture Name	Start (0 Iterations)	50 Iterations	100 Iterations	250 Iterations	500 Iterations	800 Iterations	1000 Iterations
P601293196H2	0.627	0.607	0.573	0.483	0.473	0.476	0.476
P601293751H3	0.696	0.656	0.601	0.460	0.000	0.000	0.000
P601293757H3	0.699	0.658	0.603	0.461	0.000	0.000	0.000
P601372298H3	0.772	0.727	0.662	0.478	0.403	0.409	0.409
P601372304H3	0.769	0.723	0.659	0.474	0.412	0.396	0.395
P601372310H3	0.768	0.721	0.656	0.471	0.409	0.393	0.393
P601372316H3	0.769	0.723	0.658	0.474	0.399	0.407	0.407
P601372856H2	0.708	0.676	0.626	0.477	0.436	0.000	0.000
P601372862H2	0.708	0.675	0.624	0.477	0.433	0.000	0.000
P601372868H2	0.708	0.675	0.624	0.478	0.436	0.000	0.000
P601372874H2	0.709	0.675	0.625	0.478	0.436	0.000	0.000

Start (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 50 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 100 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 150 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 200 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 250 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 300 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 350 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 400 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 450 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 500 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 600 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 700 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 800 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 900 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

Template Building: 1000 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):

-  ⇤ ← Revision 11 as of 2016-05-04 11:41:58 → 
  Size: 3108
  Editor: DianeLambert
  Comment:
+   ← Revision 19 as of 2016-05-05 10:18:31 → ⇥
  Size: 6522
  Editor: DianeLambert
  Comment:
-Deletions are marked like this.
+Additions are marked like this.
 Line 1:
-= Test F3F3 - Analysis =
+= Test F3F3: Clark and Tikir Photometric Function - Analysis =

Since the Clark and Tikir photometric function behaved so differently to the Lommel-Seeliger photometric function during testing, the sub-test results are analyzed here in detail. The F3F3 sub-test digital terrain model (Clark and Tikir photometric function) suffered from pervasive degradation with every processing step performed, eventually failing to build topography for a subset of landmarks at the 5cm tiling step. This failure is illustrated by the 5cm Landmark Test, reported below.

== 5cm Landmark Test ==

'''Background:''' A subset of new landmarks (28 of 225) created during the 5cm tile failed to achieve minimum image correlations across the images. At 5cm each landmarks contains approximately 12 Detailed Survey PolyCam images. At this scale elimination of low correlating images is not allowed, instead low-correlating images must be aligned by hand. On investigation it was found that the lithos template degraded rapidly with iteration leading to rapid loss of image correlation scores. This behavior was found to be pervasive across landmarks of all latitudes within the TAG site region, all available viewing conditions and all ground sample distances (GSDs) including the start model landmarks at 35cm, 75cm, and 150cm GSD.

'''Methodology:'''
-Line 6:
+Line 14:
-'''LITHOS Image Correlation Score During Template Building:'''
+'''LITHOS Image Correlation Score During Template Building:'''<<BR>>
-Line 8:
+Line 16:
-||'''Picture Name'''||'''Start (0 Iterations)'''||'''50 Iterations'''||'''100 Iterations'''||'''250 Iterations'''||'''500 Iterations'''||'''750 Iterations'''||'''1000 Iterations'''||
+||'''Picture Name'''||'''Start (0 Iterations)'''||'''50 Iterations'''||'''100 Iterations'''||'''250 Iterations'''||'''500 Iterations'''||'''800 Iterations'''||'''1000 Iterations'''||
||P601293196H2||0.839||0.896||0.928||0.959||0.963||0.962||0.962||
||P601293751H3||0.871||0.916||0.940||0.962||0.966||0.966||0.965||
||P601293757H3||0.871||0.918||0.942||0.964||0.968||0.967||0.967||
||P601372298H3||0.903||0.943||0.956||0.963||0.963||0.962||0.962||
||P601372304H3||0.902||0.943||0.958||0.965||0.965||0.965||0.964||
||P601372310H3||0.901||0.942||0.956||0.965||0.965||0.964||0.964||
||P601372316H3||0.902||0.943||0.957||0.965||0.965||0.965||0.964||
||P601372856H2||0.875||0.932||0.954||0.967||0.966||0.964||0.964||
||P601372862H2||0.874||0.931||0.954||0.967||0.966||0.965||0.964||
||P601372868H2||0.874||0.931||0.953||0.967||0.966||0.965||0.964||
||P601372874H2||0.874||0.931||0.953||0.967||0.966||0.964||0.964||
'''F3F3 - Clark and Tikir Photometric Function:'''
||'''Picture Name'''||'''Start (0 Iterations)'''||'''50 Iterations'''||'''100 Iterations'''||'''250 Iterations'''||'''500 Iterations'''||'''800 Iterations'''||'''1000 Iterations'''||
||P601293196H2||0.627||0.607||0.573||0.483||0.473||0.476||0.476||
||P601293751H3||0.696||0.656||0.601||0.460||0.000||0.000||0.000||
||P601293757H3||0.699||0.658||0.603||0.461||0.000||0.000||0.000||
||P601372298H3||0.772||0.727||0.662||0.478||0.403||0.409||0.409||
||P601372304H3||0.769||0.723||0.659||0.474||0.412||0.396||0.395||
||P601372310H3||0.768||0.721||0.656||0.471||0.409||0.393||0.393||
||P601372316H3||0.769||0.723||0.658||0.474||0.399||0.407||0.407||
||P601372856H2||0.708||0.676||0.626||0.477||0.436||0.000||0.000||
||P601372862H2||0.708||0.675||0.624||0.477||0.433||0.000||0.000||
||P601372868H2||0.708||0.675||0.624||0.478||0.436||0.000||0.000||
||P601372874H2||0.709||0.675||0.625||0.478||0.436||0.000||0.000||
-Line 10:
+Line 42:
-'''Start:'''<<BR>>
+'''Start (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 15:
+Line 46:
-'''Template Building: 50 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 50 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 19:
+Line 50:
-'''Template Building: 100 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 100 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 23:
+Line 54:
-'''Template Building: 150 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 150 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 27:
+Line 58:
-'''Template Building: 200 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 200 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 31:
+Line 62:
-'''Template Building: 250 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 250 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 35:
+Line 66:
-'''Template Building: 300 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 300 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 39:
+Line 70:
-'''Template Building: 350 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 350 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 43:
+Line 74:
-'''Template Building: 400 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 400 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 47:
+Line 78:
-'''Template Building: 450 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 450 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 51:
+Line 82:
-'''Template Building: 500 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 500 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 55:
+Line 86:
-'''Template Building: 600 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 600 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 59:
+Line 90:
-'''Template Building: 700 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 700 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 63:
+Line 94:
-'''Template Building: 800 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 800 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 67:
+Line 98:
-'''Template Building: 900 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 900 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>
-Line 71:
+Line 102:
-'''Template Building: 1000 Iterations:'''<<BR>>
+'''Template Building: 1000 Iterations (F3F1 left, F3F3 right):'''<<BR>>