Differences between revisions 7 and 27 (spanning 20 versions)
Revision 7 as of 2015-11-18 14:51:28
Size: 1066
Editor: DianeLambert
Comment:
Revision 27 as of 2015-12-07 13:26:03
Size: 1959
Editor: DianeLambert
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 1: Line 1:
= Spacecraft Zenith Variations: Comparison of Results = ## page was renamed from Test11STU Comparative Results
## page was renamed from Spacecraft Zenith Variations
## page was renamed from Comparison
= Spacecraft Zenith Variations =
Line 3: Line 6:
== Discussion == == Test Over11 S/T/U Comparative Results ==
Line 5: Line 8:
'''Minima'''
Line 7: Line 9:
Figure ?? illustrates the minimum uncertainty and RMSs for each test, and at which iteration each minimum occurs. The following patterns are apparent: The measures of accuracy are plotted for each test in figures ?? to ?? under Tables and Figures (below).

'''Figure 1: Minima'''

{{attachment:Minima-100-resized.png}}

Figure 1
illustrates the minimum uncertainty and RMSs for each test, and at which iteration each minimum occurs. The following patterns are apparent:
Line 9: Line 17:
 *  * Test S consistently gives the largest RMS but the smallest formal uncertainty.
 * CompareOBJ RMS (with and without optimal translation and rotation varies across tests by less than 0.2cm, although Test U consistently archives the minimum RMS in significantly fewer iterations.
Line 19: Line 28:
{{attachment:CompMapVecRMS-resized.png}} {{attachment:CompMapVec-resized.png}}
Line 23: Line 32:
{{attachment:CompOBJRMS-resized.png}} {{attachment:CompareOBJRMS-resized.png}}
Line 31: Line 40:
{{attachment:transit200.png}} {{attachment:transitIt20200.png}}
{{attachment:transitIt40200.png}}
Line 35: Line 45:
{{attachment:transposedTransit200.png}} {{attachment:transposedTransitIt20200.png}}
{{attachment:transposedTransitIt40200.png}}
Line 40: Line 51:
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFU-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png}}
Line 41: Line 54:
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png}} {{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFU-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png}}

Spacecraft Zenith Variations

Test Over11 S/T/U Comparative Results

The measures of accuracy are plotted for each test in figures ?? to ?? under Tables and Figures (below).

Figure 1: Minima

Minima-100-resized.png

Figure 1 illustrates the minimum uncertainty and RMSs for each test, and at which iteration each minimum occurs. The following patterns are apparent:

  • Test U achieves the minimum value for every measure in the least number of iterations: 5 to 15 iterations sooner than Test T; and 15 to 20 iterations sooner than Test S (excluding Test S - CompMapVec RMS).

  • Test S consistently gives the largest RMS but the smallest formal uncertainty.
  • CompareOBJ RMS (with and without optimal translation and rotation varies across tests by less than 0.2cm, although Test U consistently archives the minimum RMS in significantly fewer iterations.

Tables and Figures

Formal Uncertainty

FormalUncertainty-resized.png

CompMapVec RMS

CompMapVec-resized.png

CompareOBJ RMS

CompareOBJRMS-resized.png

CompareOBJ With Opt Tran & Rot

CompOBJwOptTranRot-resized.png

Traces Running North_South

transitIt20200.png transitIt40200.png

Traces Running West-East

transposedTransitIt20200.png transposedTransitIt40200.png

Heat Plots

heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFU-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png

heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFU-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png

Test Over11STU Comparative Results (last edited 2015-12-16 16:45:24 by DianeLambert)