Differences between revisions 1 and 16 (spanning 15 versions)
Revision 1 as of 2015-11-13 14:35:55
Size: 1739
Editor: DianeLambert
Comment:
Revision 16 as of 2015-11-25 17:15:13
Size: 2503
Editor: DianeLambert
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 1: Line 1:
## page was renamed from Over11S
Line 2: Line 3:
Line 4: Line 6:
Image suite: One 5cm resolution image for each Sun&S/C combination:
 Sun at 45deg, -0, -45deg;

 S/C at every 45deg Azimuth; 0, 30deg, 60deg Zenith.

Model
bigmap parameters: GSD = 1cm, Q = 200 (width=4m), centered at REGION.MAP, 966, 1005 (lat, wlong).
Evaluation bigmap parameters: GSD = 1cm, Q = 200 (width=4m), centered at REGION.MAP, 966, 1005 (pixel/line location).
Line 13: Line 10:
Please see results under Tables and Figures, below.

An inspection of the transits and heat plots reveals that, at 50 iterations, the solution has not converged. The North-South and West-East central transits continue to drift with the heights monotonically increasing. This corresponds with a decreasing residual and somewhat diverging RMS values.

== Tables and Figures ==

{{attachment:Over11S-resized.png}}
Line 15: Line 20:
||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||6.305||1.868||1.074||
||'''Formal Uncertainty (cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||4.589||3.357||1.043||1.660||
Line 20: Line 25:
||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||1.367||0.737||1.175||
||'''Formal Uncertainty (cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||3.841||1.537||0.882||1.199||
Line 25: Line 30:
||'''Iteration'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||1||1.158||0.635||1.205||
||2||1.089||0.557||1.227||
||3||1.072||0.505||1.199||
||5||1.022||0.447||1.175||
||10||0.973||0.410||1.035||
||15||0.925||0.416||0.861||
||20||0.884||0.446||0.839||
||'''Iteration'''||'''Formal Uncertainty (cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)'''||'''CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)'''||'''CompMapVec-RMS(cm)'''||
||1||2.662||1.331||0.785||1.376||
||2||3.476||1.263||0.687||1.501||
||3||3.122||1.239||0.632||1.593||
||5||3.134||1.211||0.578||1.685||
||10||3.394||1.171||0.527||1.749||
||15||2.968||1.146||0.518||1.779||
||20||2.284||1.110||0.507||1.892||
||25||2.173||1.060||0.517||1.947||
||30||1.923||1.035||0.527||1.984||
||35||1.848||1.036||0.566||2.002||
||40||1.510||1.077||0.608||1.996||
||45||1.444||1.152||0.650||2.048||
||50||1.431||1.253||0.686||2.081||
Line 37: Line 48:
'''Traces Running North-South:'''
Line 40: Line 49:

'''Traces Running West-East:'''
Line 44: Line 50:
Line 48: Line 53:
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepA-1cm-4m.png}}

{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB001-1cm-4m.png}}

{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB010-1cm-4m.png}}

{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFT-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepA-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB001-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB010-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB030-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png}}
{{attachment:heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB050-1cm-4m.png}}
Line 60: Line 64:
{{attachment:EE0057-It001.jpg}} {{attachment:EE0057_It001.jpg}}
Line 65: Line 69:
{{attachment:EE0057-It010.jpg}} {{attachment:EE0057_It010.jpg}}
Line 70: Line 74:
{{attachment:EE0057-It020.jpg}} {{attachment:EE0057_It020.jpg}}

Test 11S - With Overlaps

Truth topography: flat-topped cone with 20deg slope within a landscape of cones and craters.

Evaluation bigmap parameters: GSD = 1cm, Q = 200 (width=4m), centered at REGION.MAP, 966, 1005 (pixel/line location).

Results

Please see results under Tables and Figures, below.

An inspection of the transits and heat plots reveals that, at 50 iterations, the solution has not converged. The North-South and West-East central transits continue to drift with the heights monotonically increasing. This corresponds with a decreasing residual and somewhat diverging RMS values.

Tables and Figures

Over11S-resized.png

10cm Tiling:

Formal Uncertainty (cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)

CompMapVec-RMS(cm)

4.589

3.357

1.043

1.660

5cm Tiling:

Formal Uncertainty (cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)

CompMapVec-RMS(cm)

3.841

1.537

0.882

1.199

5cm Iterations:

Iteration

Formal Uncertainty (cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS(cm)

CompareOBJ-RMS with Opt Trans & Rot (cm)

CompMapVec-RMS(cm)

1

2.662

1.331

0.785

1.376

2

3.476

1.263

0.687

1.501

3

3.122

1.239

0.632

1.593

5

3.134

1.211

0.578

1.685

10

3.394

1.171

0.527

1.749

15

2.968

1.146

0.518

1.779

20

2.284

1.110

0.507

1.892

25

2.173

1.060

0.517

1.947

30

1.923

1.035

0.527

1.984

35

1.848

1.036

0.566

2.002

40

1.510

1.077

0.608

1.996

45

1.444

1.152

0.650

2.048

50

1.431

1.253

0.686

2.081

Center Traces:

transit200.png

CompMapVec RMS HeatMaps:

heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepA-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB001-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB010-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB020-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB030-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB040-1cm-4m.png heatPlot-T11RFS-05stepB050-1cm-4m.png

Landmark Display after 1 iteration:

EE0057_It001.jpg

Landmark Display after 10 iterations:

EE0057_It010.jpg

Landmark Display after 20 iterations:

EE0057_It020.jpg

Test Over11S Results (last edited 2015-12-07 17:00:37 by DianeLambert)