Differences between revisions 29 and 30
Revision 29 as of 2015-10-26 10:08:15
Size: 2174
Editor: JohnWeirich
Comment:
Revision 30 as of 2015-10-26 15:25:55
Size: 2208
Editor: JohnWeirich
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 54: Line 54:

{{attachment:comp_MOD20S.png}}

Test11S:

Building topography with Sun Az 45, 0, -45, S/C Az every 45, S/C Zenith 0, 30, 60.

Results Summary:

CompareOBJ with translate produces results I don't trust. Without translate is probably okay, though noticed the large mismatch between the two at step 40 (9 vs 2 cm). Also notice that once I start auto aligning the top of the boulder drops down.

RMS Values:

STEP

COMPAREOBJ(km)(w/ trans)

CompareOBJ (km) w/o trans

compMapVec(m)

NOTES

step01

5.17

23.2

22.4

align by hand

step02

5.40

20.0

18.8

had to delete images for step3

step03

4.95

18.1

16.5

step05

4.27

15.8

13.2

autoalign start step6

step10

3.24

12.5

5.86

step15

2.57

11.8

3.56

step20

2.13

11.1

2.05

step30

1.52

10.0

0.93

step40

1.22

9.27

2.27

step50

0.93

8.78

3.74

step100

0.62

7.03

8.02

Traces:

out50.png

Landmark Display:

step01 display001.jpg

step40 display040.jpg

step300 dispaly_300.jpg

Test make new truth centered on maplet:

Loaded the bigmap the truth was made from, so the topography will account for any drifting of the landmark.

STEP

COMPAREOBJ(cm)(w/ trans)

CompareOBJ (cm) w/o trans

compMapVec(cm)

NOTES

step100

0.47

7.34

12.4

PIT20Scomp.png

out2.png

Test make bigmap w/ trim:

Made a bigmap centered on the same lat/lon as the original truth, then trimmed the bigmap to Q=44 so there was no black space.

STEP

COMPAREOBJ(cm)(w/ trans)

CompareOBJ (cm) w/o trans

compMapVec(cm)

NOTES

step100

4.74

6.43

38.7

compMapVec shouldn't mean anything since the Q is different between truth and model

Run the model even further:

Run the model out many iterations further and track the RMS for CompareOBJ with and without translate.

MOD20S_RMS_both_longer.png

comp_MOD20S.png

Test11S Results (last edited 2015-11-25 10:29:36 by DianeLambert)